Anton and James Peraire-Bueno walked free after a federal judge determined their 2023 transaction targeting automated Ethereum bots contained no actionable deception, bringing an end to the government’s landmark criminal prosecution over the blockchain practice known as MEV.
A federal judge decided that outsmarting automated Ethereum bots does not constitute wire fraud, dismissing the government’s landmark criminal prosecution over an alleged MEV exploit and clearing two MIT-educated brothers who had been accused of pocketing $25 million in just 12 seconds.
On Nov. 16, U.S. District Judge Jessica Clarke in Manhattan cleared Anton and James Peraire-Bueno of wire fraud, wire fraud conspiracy, and money laundering conspiracy charges, granting them a judgment of acquittal after their case was reviewed in her official court opinion.
This decision arrives twelve months after a deadlocked jury forced Clarke to call a mistrial in November 2025, instructing the court clerk to ensure the case is officially closed.
“It is a trustless, highly adversarial environment with no terms of use,” Clarke wrote of Ethereum.
How the Ethereum Trade Was Executed
Unconfirmed Ethereum transfers wait inside a public holding area called the mempool until a validator—the network participant selected to process the upcoming block—adds them to the chain. Automated bots constantly scan this queue to seize maximal extractable value, or MEV, which represents the extra profit open to anyone dictating transaction order.
Automated programs rely most frequently on a tactic called the sandwich. A bot detects an incoming large purchase, acquires the asset moments earlier, allows the victim’s order to drive values higher, and immediately offloads its holdings once the price is inflated.
Rather than assembling blocks themselves, most validators purchase complete versions from dedicated builders via onchain middlemen referred to as relays. These intermediaries hide a block’s transaction details until the validator signs a binding commitment to broadcast it, preventing validators from peeking at and stealing a builder’s profitable trades.
According to the court’s opinion, the brothers laid a trap in April 2023. They submitted eight decoy transfers designed to lure in sandwich bots—automated scripts that purchase right before another user’s order and sell immediately afterward—allowing the price spread to be captured as profit.
Once their personal validator took its turn, a relay named Ultrasound delivered a block packed with the bots’ sandwich transactions. The validator approved the block’s header—a condensed overview of its contents—while leaving two vital data fields blank at zero, effectively outlining an impossible block. Because the relay failed to verify those entries, the full transaction data was released anyway.
Holding the bots’ trade data, the brothers assembled a custom block of their own. This new version preserved the bots’ initial purchases while swapping out the original bait for orders that dumped the exact tokens the bots had just acquired, ensuring the market was crashed before the automated programs could offload their positions.
The automated bots suffered losses totaling roughly $25 million, while the brothers’ validator was penalized approximately 1 ether, an amount valued at just a few thousand dollars.
Why the Court Ruled the Ethereum Trade Was Not Fraud
Proving wire fraud demands a material misrepresentation, meaning an intentional falsehood that directly influences the party being deceived.
Judge Clarke noted that the decoy transactions offered no guarantees, explaining that “no trader who places a transaction in the public mempool would agree to be sandwiched.”
She noted further that prosecutors presented no proof showing an unconfirmed transaction constitutes a binding pledge to be bundled. Meanwhile, the bogus signature proved irrelevant because the relay completely bypassed verifying the altered data fields, meaning the falsification “had no effect on the behavior of its recipient.”
Clarke emphasized that the verdict hinged strictly on whether the actions met the legal definition of wire fraud, setting aside broader questions of ethics or morality. Pointing to a 2022 Second Circuit precedent, she noted that behavior deemed “improper, objectionable, or even despicable” falls short of criminal fraud, even while acknowledging that the brothers concealed their strategy and likely undermined the intended purpose for which the relay software was designed.
This outcome leaves the automated bot operators—who were executing sandwich trades themselves when they were caught—without a criminal prosecution backing their claims.
Authorities froze just a single digital wallet containing roughly $3 million of the funds, while the brothers successfully transferred the remaining balance elsewhere before October 2023 was reached.

